Genetics of Disease (Medical Interventions)
Unit 2: Unit 2.2 Our Genetic Future (Gene Therapy)MI 2.2Bio-Molecular Technology

Compare Viral Vectors

Compare AAV, lentivirus, and adenovirus on integration, payload size, and immune response to pick the best vector for a stated need.

Builds on (2 levels back)inferred · high confidence
  • DNA/RNA base pairing: Sequence and codon tasks depend on reading bases in order.
  • Read a genetics model: Pedigrees, karyotypes, and charts are models that need a key.

Prerequisites are inferred: pending teacher review.

Re-learn the skill with worked practice and clear examples.

Compare the three vectors across all three columns to pick the best one for a stated need.

Step 1: Read down each column
Integration, payload size, and immune response are the three trade-offs. Match the patient's need to the right column.
VectorIntegrates into genome?Payload (max insert)Immune response
AAVNo (stays separate, episomal)Small (~4.7 kb)Low
LentivirusYes (inserts into host DNA)Large (~8 kb)Low
AdenovirusNo (stays separate)Medium (~7.5 kb)High
Comparison table of three gene-therapy delivery vectors. AAV does not integrate into the genome, carries a small payload (~4.7 kb), and provokes a low immune response. Lentivirus integrates into the host DNA, carries a large payload (~8 kb), and provokes a low immune response. Adenovirus does not integrate, carries a medium payload (~7.5 kb), and provokes a high immune response.
Step 2: Match need to feature
Need a permanent fix in dividing cells -> integrating (lentivirus). Need a big gene -> large payload (lentivirus). Want to avoid a strong immune reaction -> low-immune vector (AAV or lentivirus, not adenovirus).
Step 3: Name the limit
Integration can be risky (it may disrupt a host gene), so 'best' depends on the specific goal, not one universal winner.
Practice

A therapy must put a permanent copy of a gene into blood stem cells that keep dividing, so the fix is not lost. Using the table, which vector fits best?

Reviewed
VectorIntegrates into genome?Payload (max insert)Immune response
AAVNo (stays separate, episomal)Small (~4.7 kb)Low
LentivirusYes (inserts into host DNA)Large (~8 kb)Low
AdenovirusNo (stays separate)Medium (~7.5 kb)High
Comparison table of three gene-therapy delivery vectors. AAV does not integrate into the genome, carries a small payload (~4.7 kb), and provokes a low immune response. Lentivirus integrates into the host DNA, carries a large payload (~8 kb), and provokes a low immune response. Adenovirus does not integrate, carries a medium payload (~7.5 kb), and provokes a high immune response.
  1. A.Lentivirus, because it integrates into the host DNA
  2. B.AAV, because it does not integrate
  3. C.Adenovirus, because it triggers a high immune response
  4. D.Any vector works equally well
Show the worked solution ▾

Answer: A. Lentivirus, because it integrates into the host DNA

  1. Step 1: Translate the need: 'Permanent in dividing cells' means the gene must copy with the DNA, so it must integrate.
  2. Step 2: Find the integrating vector: The table shows lentivirus is the one that integrates.

Why it's right: Only lentivirus integrates into host DNA, so its gene copies into every daughter cell: a permanent fix in dividing cells.

Why the others miss:
  • B: Non-integrating AAV can be lost as cells divide.
  • C: A high immune response is a drawback, not a reason to pick it.
  • D: The vectors differ in the table, so they are not equal for this need.

Aligned to Bio-Molecular Technology · reading level ~grade 9

A team wants to avoid a strong immune reaction in the patient. Using the table, which vector should they AVOID?

Reviewed
VectorIntegrates into genome?Payload (max insert)Immune response
AAVNo (stays separate, episomal)Small (~4.7 kb)Low
LentivirusYes (inserts into host DNA)Large (~8 kb)Low
AdenovirusNo (stays separate)Medium (~7.5 kb)High
Comparison table of three gene-therapy delivery vectors. AAV does not integrate into the genome, carries a small payload (~4.7 kb), and provokes a low immune response. Lentivirus integrates into the host DNA, carries a large payload (~8 kb), and provokes a low immune response. Adenovirus does not integrate, carries a medium payload (~7.5 kb), and provokes a high immune response.
  1. A.Adenovirus, because it has a high immune response
  2. B.AAV, because it has a low immune response
  3. C.Lentivirus, because it has a low immune response
  4. D.All three cause equally high immune responses
Show the worked solution ▾

Answer: A. Adenovirus, because it has a high immune response

  1. Step 1: Find the immune column: Read 'Immune response' for each vector.
  2. Step 2: Spot the high one: Adenovirus is the only one marked High, so it is the one to avoid for low immune reaction.

Why it's right: The table lists adenovirus as high immune response, so it is the vector to avoid when minimizing immune reaction.

Why the others miss:
  • B: AAV is low immune response: a good choice, not one to avoid.
  • C: Lentivirus is low immune response: also fine here.
  • D: Only adenovirus is High; the others are Low.

Aligned to Bio-Molecular Technology · reading level ~grade 9

Where you'd see this
  • In Unit 2.2 Our Genetic Future (Gene Therapy), this skill turns class evidence into a result another person can check.
Video library
Watch: Compare Viral Vectors
Viral Vectors Overview
ASGCT · ~4 min
Guided notes

Fill these in as you work through the lesson.

Big idea: Pick a gene-therapy vector by matching the patient's need to the table: integration, payload size, and immune response.
Key terms: write the meaning
  • Vector (hollowed-out virus that carries a gene):  
  • Integration (inserting the gene into the host's own DNA):  
  • Payload (how big a gene the vector can carry):  
  • Immune response (how strongly the body reacts to the vector):  
The rule

To choose a vector, match the need to a column: a permanent fix needs   (lentivirus), a big gene needs a large  , and avoiding a strong reaction means a low  .

Check yourself
  1. Which vector integrates, and when would you want that? 
  2. Which vector carries the largest gene? 
  3. Which vector would you avoid if immune response must stay low? 
Work one example

A 5 kb gene needs a permanent fix in dividing cells with low immune response. Use the table to pick the vector and name the column that decides it.