Biotechnology for Health (Biomedical Innovations)
Unit 1: Problem 1: Effective ER DesignBI 1.1Biomedical Innovation: research & information literacy

Cite prior art

Find existing designs and ideas, then give credit with an accurate citation instead of claiming them as your own.

Builds on (2 levels back)inferred · high confidence
  • Telling your own ideas from someone else's: You can only credit a source if you can first notice which parts of your work came from outside, not from you.
  • Parts of a basic citation: Knowing that a citation names the author, the title, and the date lets you build one that points a reader back to the original.

Prerequisites are inferred: pending teacher review.

Re-learn the skill with worked practice and clear examples.

Citing prior art means searching for designs and ideas that already exist, using them on purpose, and giving clear attribution so your own contribution is visible.

Step 1: Search the prior art
Prior art is the existing work in your area: earlier ER layouts, published designs, patents. Engineers look at it first so they do not redo what exists and so they can build on it.
Step 2: Give attribution
Attribution is naming the source you used. When you reuse a layout or idea, you write a citation (author, title, date, and where to find it) right where you use it.
Step 3: Separate your new part
Citing prior art actually makes your own idea stronger: once it is clear what already existed, the reader can see exactly what you added that is new.
Practice

Your ER report reuses a 'fast-track' area for minor injuries that you read about in a published hospital-design article, and you present it without naming the article. What is the problem and the fix?

Reviewed
  1. A.No problem; ideas you read are automatically yours
  2. B.It is plagiarism; fix it by citing the article you took the idea from
  3. C.The problem is the idea is too old; fix it by deleting it
  4. D.The problem is the report is too long; fix it by cutting the section
Show the worked solution ▾

Answer: B. It is plagiarism; fix it by citing the article you took the idea from

  1. Step 1: Identify the borrowed prior art: The fast-track idea came from a published article, so it is prior art, not your original idea.
  2. Step 2: Apply the rule: Using prior art without attribution is plagiarism. The fix is to cite the article: name its author, title, and date where you use the idea.

Why it's right: Presenting a borrowed idea as your own without crediting the source is plagiarism, and the correct fix is to add a citation that attributes the idea to the article.

Why the others miss:
  • A: Reading an idea does not make it yours; it still belongs to the author who published it.
  • C: The age of the idea is not the issue, and deleting useful prior art is not the fix.
  • D: Length is not the issue; the missing credit is.

Aligned to Information literacy: attribution & prior art · reading level ~grade 9

Where you'd see this
  • A design team's report has a 'Prior work' section that cites each existing layout it borrowed from, so reviewers can see what is reused and what is new.
Video library
Watch: Cite prior art
Patent Search in Three Simple Steps
John Ferrell, Esq. · ~6 min
Guided notes

Fill these in as you work through the lesson.

Big idea: Prior art is the existing work that came before your design; citing it means clearly giving credit and pointing readers back to the original so your own new idea stands apart.
Key terms: write the meaning
  • Prior art (designs that already exist):  
  • Attribution (giving credit to the source):  
  • Citation (the labeled pointer to a source):  
  • Plagiarism (using work without credit):  
The rule

When part of my design comes from work that already exists, called  , I must give   by writing a   that names the author, title, and date: otherwise it is  .

Check yourself
  1. What is one reason an engineer searches for prior art before starting a new design? 
  2. Which parts of a source do you need to write even a basic citation? 
  3. How is borrowing an idea and citing it different from plagiarism? 
Work one example

Your ER layout reuses a 'fast-track' minor-injury area you read about in a 2021 hospital design article by R. Lee. Write a sentence for your report that uses the idea AND credits the prior art, then explain what would make it plagiarism instead.